Valor's Verdict

Your ultimate destination for comic book and fantasy debates. We provide in-depth respect threads, 'who would win' scenarios, and curated reading orders.

Welcome to Valor’s Verdict, the ultimate destination for fans of comic books, fantasy, and all things fictional!

Have you ever found yourself debating who would triumph in a battle between two titans of fiction? Do you search for the definitive breakdown of your favorite character’s powers and feats? You’ve come to the right place.

The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

Buster Scruggs - The San Saba Songbird

Buster Scruggs - The San Saba Songbird

Buster Scruggs is a cheerful singing cowboy wandering across the old west. Although he never means to, Buster often finds many a low-down varmint on his travels. When that dreadful event comes to pass, Buster is forced to educate them that he is a…

Marvel Comics (Earth-616)

Dario Agger - the Minotaur

Dario Agger - the Minotaur

Dario Agger is the CEO of Roxxon Energies, a ruthless billionaire who destroys the environment and kills people for profit. He sold his soul as a child to become a monstrous minotaur, seeking revenge on the pirates who killed his family. As both a…

Inheritance Cycle

Durza - The Shade

Durza - The Shade

Once there was an orphan named Carsaib, wandering in the desert after his parents were killed by his tribe. Carsaib was taken in by a lone sorcerer and trained in the arts of controlling and manipulating spirits. However, when bandits killed his t…

Post-Crisis

Etrigan the Demon

Etrigan the Demon

Etrigan the Demon is the son of the Demon Belial, whose power was so great that Belial created another son, Merlin, to bind him. Merlin and Etrigan regularly interfered in human affairs. When Merlin was attacked by Morgaine le Faye’s demonic army,…

Lumpy Touch

Garfield - Lumpy Touch

Garfield - Lumpy Touch

Garfield used to be a small orange cat and the pet of Jon Arbuckle. However, one day he shed his mortal form and became a creature of flesh, claws and teeth. He attacked Jon’s friend and former roommate, Lyman, but ultimately was unsuccessful in k…

Old Spice

Isaiah Mustafa - Old Spice

Isaiah Mustafa - Old Spice

Isaiah Mustafa, also known as Old Spice Guy II, embodies ultimate masculinity, transforming his surroundings to fit the sexiest scenario possible, powered by Old Spice Body Wash and Deodorant.