Valor's Verdict

Your ultimate destination for comic book and fantasy debates. We provide in-depth respect threads, 'who would win' scenarios, and curated reading orders.

Welcome to Valor’s Verdict, the ultimate destination for fans of comic books, fantasy, and all things fictional!

Have you ever found yourself debating who would triumph in a battle between two titans of fiction? Do you search for the definitive breakdown of your favorite character’s powers and feats? You’ve come to the right place.

Marvel Comics (Earth-616)

Norman Osborn - the Red Goblin

Norman Osborn - the Red Goblin

After his defeat at the end of Superior Spider-Man, Norman Osborn sought revenge against Spider-Man but was unable to access his Green Goblin powers due to nanobots in his bloodstream. He hired mercenaries to steal a piece of the Carnage symbiote …

Phil of the Future

Phil - of the Future

Phil - of the Future

Phil Diffy is an ordinary child, albeit a very well-connected one, that attends public school in the small town of Pickford. At least, on the outside. What the world doesn’t know is he’s actually a time traveler from the year 2121, and he’s been s…

Super Mario

Piranha Plants

Piranha Plants

The Piranha Plant is a deadly plant and a staple unit of King Bowser’s army. These man-eating plants have spread their vines far and wide, residing in the Mushroom Kingdom, Sarasaland, across the galaxy and even to the Zelda universe. Most Piranha…

Pokemon Anime

Snorlax

Snorlax

Snorlax is a sleeping Normal-type Pokemon owned by Ash Ketchum, captured in the Orange Islands after nearly driving a grapefruit company out of business with his massive appetite. He spends most of his time sleeping at Professor Oak’s lab but is s…

The Ren and Stimpy show

Spider-man

Spider-man

After Powdered ToastMan was trapped under the mind control of the evil genius Dr Dough Naught, the role of defender of breakfast had to be filled by his friend Spider-man. But after the controlled hero is let loose on the city, Spidey had to jump …

Marvel Comics (Earth-96283)

Spider-Man - Tobey Maguire, Sam Raimi's trilogy

Spider-Man - Tobey Maguire, Sam Raimi's trilogy

Peter Parker was a brilliant but socially inept student. After being orphaned, Peter moved in with his Uncle Ben and Aunt May. While attending a field trip Peter was bitten by a genetically modified spider and gained spider-like abilities, which i…