Valor's Verdict

Your ultimate destination for comic book and fantasy debates. We provide in-depth respect threads, 'who would win' scenarios, and curated reading orders.

Welcome to Valor’s Verdict, the ultimate destination for fans of comic books, fantasy, and all things fictional!

Have you ever found yourself debating who would triumph in a battle between two titans of fiction? Do you search for the definitive breakdown of your favorite character’s powers and feats? You’ve come to the right place.

DC Comics (Post-Crisis)

Ratcatcher

Ratcatcher

Otis Flannegan was a ratcatcher for the Gotham City Sanitation Department who claimed that he could train rats to attack. Flannegan lost his job when he killed a man in a barroom brawl, stabbing him to death. After spending 15 years in Gotham Stat…

RackaRacka

Ronald McDonald

Ronald McDonald

Ronald McDonald is the psychotic, murderous & cruel former mascot of McDonald’s and the main protagonist of the RackaRacka videos.

Star Wars Canon

Sabine Wren

Sabine Wren

Sabine Wren is a member of the Rebel cell known as the Spectres. Hailing from the Mandalorian planet Krownest, Sabine was once a cadet at an Imperial academy, where she designed weapons for the Empire. Her guilt led her to leave behind the Empire …

SCP Foundation

SCP-4233 - The Dreadnought Sea Champion

SCP-4233 - The Dreadnought Sea Champion

SCP-4233 is a Keter-class amphibious humanoid entity of unknown origin and composition, physically resembling a disproportionately large human in a late-19th century diving suit with a rigid copper helmet featuring a glass viewing window and weigh…

Shovel Knight

Specter Knight

Specter Knight

Specter Knight is the earliest member of the Order of No Quarter, a group of eight knights that serve the villainous Enchantress. He is an undead ninja warrior wielding a scythe and various magic curios to guard his village, the Lich Yard. He was …

DC Comics (Netherrealm Studios)

The Flash - Injustice

The Flash - Injustice

For years Barry Allen operated as the Flash and as a member of the Justice League. After Metropolis was destroyed and his grandson along with it, he joined Superman’s Regime. Barry questioned how far they went for 5 years, and after the death of S…