Valor's Verdict

Your ultimate destination for comic book and fantasy debates. We provide in-depth respect threads, 'who would win' scenarios, and curated reading orders.

Welcome to Valor’s Verdict, the ultimate destination for fans of comic books, fantasy, and all things fictional!

Have you ever found yourself debating who would triumph in a battle between two titans of fiction? Do you search for the definitive breakdown of your favorite character’s powers and feats? You’ve come to the right place.

Marvel Cinematic Universe

Avengers - Rogers: The Musical

Avengers - Rogers: The Musical

When the city of New York, and the world at large, was threatened by an alien invasion spearheaded by the Asgardian despot Loki, six-seven heroes assembled to become a symbol for the power of mankind, The Avengers! Rogers: The Musical retells thei…

Marvel Cinematic Universe

Carl Creel - Crusher

Carl Creel - Crusher

Creel was a boxer, nicknamed the Crusher. Turns out any opponent has a glass jaw when you have steel fists under your gloves. Garrett thought he’d be an asset. Now, once Creel touches a substance, he can absorb it and somehow consciously transform…

Unbreakable Trilogy

David Dunn - The Overseer

David Dunn - The Overseer

David Dunn, also known as The Overseer, is a superhero with superhuman strength, durability, and extrasensory perception. Real name David Dunn, aliases include Unbreakable Man, The Green Guard, and Tip-Toe Man. Allies: Joseph Dunn. Enemies: Crimin…

Marvel Comics (Earth-616)

Gabby Kinney - Honey Badger

Gabby Kinney - Honey Badger

Gabby Kinney is a clone of X-23 designed by Alchamax as a new generation of assassin. Most of the clones were failed experiments, developing none of Laura’s powers or emotion, but Gabby was a near perfect clone, developing the ability to generate …

DC Comics (New 52/Rebirth)

Ghost-Maker

Ghost-Maker

The Ghost-Maker is a vigilante who trained with several of Batman’s mentors around the world. A rival of the Dark Knight since his youth, he is a radical crime-fighter who will not hesitate to kill if deemed necessary and sees crime-fighting as an…

Gorillaz

Gorillaz

Gorillaz

In 1999 a greasy cartoon character from Stoke-on-Trent, England had a dream: To become the most wealthy and famous musician in the world. His method of doing so, simple: make a deal with Beelzebub for his immortal soul. Doing so would set off a se…